His Dark Materials series three review – Ruth Wilson is as seductive as Satan (2024)

‘We’ve lost the rear oscillator,” says the snow leopard to Lord Asriel. James McAvoy’s face tightens, because his fascinatingly realised steampunkish flying machine is on a collision course with what air crash investigators call, in their quaint way, the ground. How does he propose to complete the recruitment drive for his war against the Authority if his corpse ends up pulled from the wreckage? Let’s not even go there. “Brace!” he yells to his daemon as he activates an appealingly old-school parachute.

Welcome to the final series of His Dark Materials (BBC One), one that will cover the action of The Amber Spyglass, the last volume of Philip Pullman’s trilogy. How poignant that the BBC has chosen the festive season to broadcast Jack Thorne’s virtuosic adaptation of Pullman’s no-less virtuosic inversion of Milton’s Paradise Lost. Not that I’m complaining, but its appearance in the yuletide schedules does clinch the point that Christmas is not the season to celebrate the birth of our redeemer, but for rampant atheism – whether in the form of the worship of mammon or Pullman’s compelling broadside against organised religion.

While in Milton’s poem Satan and his cohorts are cast out from heaven, Pullman’s fantasy has it that the empyrean is already ruled by an angel just as hubristic and power-crazed as that would-be usurper. “For many millennia the Authority has ruled the kingdom of heaven with absolute control,” says one angel to another in a delicately animated sequence of diaphanous spirits in a starry skyscape. “He named himself the Creator, the Father, the Almighty. He is none of those but just an angel like us.” I’m no theologian but it’s a speech that problematises the narrative that around this time 2022 years ago the almighty sent his only son to wash away our sins.

Thorne doesn’t balk at dramatising these weighty theological matters. Indeed, this opening episode has a contemplative mood, fittingly because we’re in the calm before the storm when Asriel will lead his mustered forces against the Authority, with the aid of Will Parry and his subtle knife, not to mention our heroine Lyra Belacqua and her manifest destiny, which is to kill death and lead the deceased back to life.

Unfortunately, though, the action sequences are all sizzle and no steak. Will unleashes his subtle knife for a fight to the death with armoured polar bear Iorek Byrnison, but it comes to nothing. Drones fly overhead but there is no battle. Even the crash landing leaves Lord Asriel with his inexcusable pony tail unruffled.

Faster than you can say “red alethiometer, yellow alethiometer”, Asriel and his snow leopard dust themselves down and rush across the countryside to spring a potential ally, Commander Ogunwe, from jail. Asriel singlehandedly kills all the guards in a scene that misfires – there is no doubt he will triumph in this task, which puts the body count in inverse relation to dramatic tension.

The CGI is superlative, though. I really do believe that an armoured polar bear is prowling the decks of a fishing trawler and that Will Parry’s miraculous blade can cut through sky to take us to other worlds.

And how lovely to see Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje as Ogunwe. He excels as a sad-eyed father whose daughter has been kidnapped and had her daemon surgically severed before she makes it home, traumatised. There is one especially poignant moment where McAvoy glances as Akinnuoye-Agbaje with empathy and also with pained envy for what is missing in his life. Unlike Ogunwe, Lord Asriel cannot soothe his daughter. He has chosen to save the world rather than accept parental responsibilities.

This theme of what parenting involves here proves more engaging than all the theology and action of the first episode. Asriel is a bad dad but outdone in parenting by his ex, Ruth Wilson’s captivatingly evil Mrs Coulter. Kidnapping then chloroforming your daughter to stop her fulfilling her manifest destiny battling crypto-fascistic priests is in no parenting manual I’ve read.

skip past newsletter promotion

after newsletter promotion

William Blake wrote that Milton, in creating a compelling Satan, was of the devil’s party without knowing it. Pullman has perhaps equally unwittingly created something similar in Mrs Coulter. Certainly Ruth Wilson’s seductively satanic turn eclipses Nicole Kidman’s merely chilly performance of the same role in the 2007 film. Wilson’s Mrs Coulter 2.0 is one-third Margaret Thatcher, one-third Cruella de Vil and one-third eloquent eyebrows – plus a succession of burgundy tops and Oxford bags that make her quite the diabolical clothes horse. It will be sad to see her get her comeuppance.

  • His Dark Materials season three is available to watch on BBC One and BBC iPlayer in the UK, and on Foxtel and Binge in Australia.

His Dark Materials series three review – Ruth Wilson is as seductive as Satan (2024)

FAQs

Is his dark material against Christianity? ›

People started wondering if His Dark Materials was anti-Christian: that stemmed from the story's premise, which was revealed to be atheistic. Shockingly, His Dark Materials wasn't more controversial, given that it railed against God, the Catholic Church and organized religion as the books progressed.

Why was His Dark Materials cancelled? ›

Season 1 adapted novel one, Northern Lights (aka The Golden Compass); season 2 pulled inspiration from novel two, The Subtle Knife; and season 3 was based on novel three, The Amber Spyglass. As a result, the HBO and BBC One series ended when the writers ran out of material from the book trilogy.

Why does Mrs. Coulter's daemon not speak? ›

Mrs. Coulter's golden monkey, on other hand, has never once spoken in His Dark Materials, likely due to how emotionally repressed she is. The golden monkey is an extension of Mrs. Coulter's emotions, and given how she rarely expresses her feelings truthfully, her daemon never talks.

Is His Dark Materials season 3 good? ›

In its third season, His Dark Materials finally strikes the right balance. Content collapsed. This season 3 conclusion to Philip Pullman's trilogy is epic on every level. Majestic locations, thought-provoking themes, and headliners Dafne Keen and James McAvoy on solid form throughout.

What is the controversy with His Dark Materials? ›

Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials series was number 8 on the Top 100 Banned/Challenged Books list for 2000-2009. In 2007, the Catholic League campaigned against The Golden Compass, declaring that it promoted atheism and attacked Christianity, in particular the Catholic church.

What is the controversy with The Golden Compass book? ›

Since the film was commissioned — and even before shooting began — religious groups were outraged, pegging "The Golden Compass" as a direct attack on organized religion, particularly Catholicism.

Why can't Lyra and Will live in the same world? ›

The book ends with Will and Lyra falling in love but realising they cannot live together in the same world, because all windows – except one from the underworld to the world of the Mulefa – must be closed to prevent the loss of Dust, because with every window opening, a Spectre would be created and that means Will must ...

Is there going to be season 4 of His Dark Materials? ›

Amir Wilson, who played Would Parry in 'His Dark Materials', has said that the show's creators want to finish it with season 3, repeating that season 4 will not take place. The actor explained, “They knew they were just going to do three seasons and leave it at that. Three seasons, three novels - it made sense”.

Is Dark season 4 coming? ›

No, the show is complete now. It has ended with a perfect climax and there isn't any thing unresolved for which the show may be renewed for a new season. The never ending loop doesn't exist anymore, so there isn't any point of making a new season. No, there will be no Dark season 4.

Why does Coulter abuse her daemon? ›

So why is this? Well essentially, it is representative of some of the inner conflict Mrs Coulter herself is feeling – remember, the daemon is merely an extension of her own self, so any anger expressed towards it is basically anger at herself.

Why is Lord Asriel's daemon a snow leopard? ›

Witches' daemons are most often birds, which suggests witches' independence and their ability to fly. Lord Asriel's daemon is a snow leopard, which reflects Lord Asriel's power. Mrs. Asriel's daemon is a beautiful but cruel monkey, which reflects her lovely appearance and deceptive personality.

Why can Mrs Coulter control the spectres? ›

In the His Dark Materials books, Mrs Coulter tells Boreal that she's able to control the Spectres through negotiation, imparting to them the idea that she'll be able to bring them to more prey by following her.

How old is Lyra in season 3? ›

This makes it vital that the show faithfully reflects this focus moving into His Dark Materials season 3. In the original third His Dark Materials novel, The Amber Spyglass, protagonists Lyra and Will are supposed to be around 12-13 years old.

Is Lord Asriel a villain in His Dark Materials? ›

In other stories, Asriel would almost certainly be the villain. In Pullman's trilogy, Asriel is complicated, arrogant, and unlikable, but in many ways he is also a heroic figure. The name Asriel is derived from Asrael, the name of a biblical angel.

How does Mary Tempt Lyra? ›

Sofia Mary was the temptress. She told Lyra the story of her falling in love, which opened Lyra up to understanding her own feelings and attraction to Will.

Is His Dark Materials based on the Bible? ›

In the process Pullman weaves together elements of modern cosmology, quantum physics, the I Ching, and especially, the Bible, for His Dark Materials is a rewriting of Paradise Lost in which “Lucifer” gets to win. The title itself comes from Book II of Paradise Lost in which Satan, on his way to Eden, must cross chaos.

Does Jesus exist in His Dark Materials? ›

Pullman has stated that Jesus was a way Dust expressed truth; as a prophet sent by the angel Sophia to preach wisdom.

Is his dark material heretical? ›

When I first read the His Dark Materials trilogy 20 years ago, I knew the books were deemed as heretical. I read them as anti-church and having a different theology from Christianity. I hadn't realised at the time that they hark back to an older heresy with roots in Judaism, Jewish Christianity and Greek philosophy.

Who is God in His Dark Materials? ›

The Authority proclaimed himself as God. However, it is unknown if God exists, as the Authority was both a fraud and an impostor. Dust was hypothesised to be the actual God.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Errol Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 6437

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Errol Quitzon

Birthday: 1993-04-02

Address: 70604 Haley Lane, Port Weldonside, TN 99233-0942

Phone: +9665282866296

Job: Product Retail Agent

Hobby: Computer programming, Horseback riding, Hooping, Dance, Ice skating, Backpacking, Rafting

Introduction: My name is Errol Quitzon, I am a fair, cute, fancy, clean, attractive, sparkling, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.